Kelsey Anderson and Val Chmerkovskiy's public disapproval of Inaba's critiques during the Season 33 finale highlights a growing disconnect between the judges and the contestants. Anderson, in particular, expressed her frustration with Inaba's scoring, which many fans perceived as overly harsh. This incident, coupled with the booing from the audience, underscores a broader issue: the need for the judging panel to evolve.
Inaba's approach to scoring has often been characterized as inconsistent and sometimes overly critical. While constructive criticism is essential in a competitive show like 'Dancing with the Stars,' the manner in which it is delivered can significantly impact the contestants' morale and the audience's perception of fairness. The fact that even seasoned professionals like Chmerkovskiy are speaking out against her comments indicates a deeper problem that needs addressing.
Moreover, the show's audience is not just composed of casual viewers but also includes die-hard fans who have followed the series for years. Their reaction to Inaba's scoring during the finale, as reported by E! News, reflects a growing dissatisfaction with the current judging dynamics. Fans want to see a fair and balanced evaluation of performances, and when that doesn't happen, it can lead to a loss of trust in the show's integrity.
Inaba's response to the backlash, as reported by Access Hollywood, was that "not everybody gets a 10." While this is undeniably true, the issue at hand is not about giving perfect scores but about the consistency and fairness of the critiques. The show thrives on its ability to bring out the best in its contestants, and when the judges' evaluations are seen as arbitrary or biased, it undermines the very essence of the competition.
In conclusion, while Carrie Ann Inaba has been an integral part of 'Dancing with the Stars,' the recent controversies and public outcry suggest that it might be time for a change in the judging panel. The show needs judges who can provide constructive feedback in a manner that is both fair and inspiring to the contestants. As 'Dancing with the Stars' continues to evolve, so too must its judging criteria to maintain its relevance and appeal to both contestants and viewers.
